Shopstack Work with us

Guides Plan

Which app gives Gold, Silver and VIP customer tags their own discount on Shopify?

Who this guide is for

This guide is for Shopify merchants who keep loyalty or member tiers as customer tags and want a different discount per tier, for example 10% off for Bronze, 15% for Silver and 20% for Gold.

We compared 5 apps found by searching the Shopify App Store for "customer tag discount", "loyalty tier discount" and "tag tier", and kept the ones whose listing names customer tags or VIP tiers. Every competitor fact comes from the app's Shopify App Store listing, checked on November 16, 2026. We did not install the other apps. Prices are per month, in US dollars, and can change.

Shopstack makes Discount Genie, one of the apps on this list. It is listed first, and every app is described from its own listing.

What Shopify does on its own

Shopify has no tier setting. Each tier becomes its own customer segment and its own discount. Each item below links the Shopify page it comes from (checked November 12, 2026).

Shopify can

  • Build a segment from a customer tag, for example customer_tags CONTAINS 'Gold'. Tags in segments are not case sensitive. Source: help.shopify.com
  • Limit a discount code or an automatic discount to Customer segments in its Eligibility section. Source: help.shopify.com
  • Recognize a segment's customers at checkout by a valid email address or phone number. Source: help.shopify.com

Shopify can’t

To give 3 tiers their own discount without an app:

  1. From your Shopify admin, go to Customers and create one segment per tier, for example customer_tags CONTAINS 'Gold'.
  2. Go to Discounts, click Create discount, and pick Amount off products or Amount off orders.
  3. Under Method, select Discount code or Automatic discount, and set the tier's value, for example 20% for Gold.
  4. In the Eligibility section, select Customer segments, pick the tier's segment, and click Add.
  5. Save, then repeat steps 2 to 4 for each other tier.

A customer who carries two tier tags, such as Gold and Silver, sits in both segments. Remove the lower tag when a customer moves up, or use an app that can exclude the higher tag from the lower tier's discount.

Which app fits your store

These apps differ most in how a tier gets its price and which plan that needs.

  • A few tag tiers as discounts, with no overlap, on a free plan: Discount Genie, on its basic free plan.
  • A tag-only order or shipping discount: Howdy Customer Tag Discount, from $19 a month.
  • The lowest monthly price: Oak Customer Tag Discount App, $4.99 a month on Basic Shopify.
  • Tier prices shown on product pages: TagTier, free for up to 2 tag rules.
  • Customers earning their tier through points: Smile, which lists VIP tiers on its Growth plan.

Best for 3 tag tiers on a free plan: Discount Genie

Discount Genie by Shopstack has 5.0 from 52 reviews on the Shopify App Store. Install it from Discount Genie on the Shopify App Store. It is a Shopify discount app built on Shopify Functions, and its customer conditions decide which tag gets which discount.

  • One discount per tier: make a discount for each tier tag, for example 20% off for Gold, 15% for Silver and 10% for Bronze. The basic free plan holds up to 3 basic discounts, so 3 tiers fit on it.
  • No double tiers: give the Silver discount two conditions, includes any Silver and excludes any Gold, matched all, so a customer who carries both tags gets one level.
  • Match modes: includes all, includes any, excludes all or excludes any of your tags.
  • Where tags work: product, order, tiered, Standard and Advanced volume, shipping and BOGO discounts, so a Gold tier can also get a better quantity break or a buy X get Y offer.
  • Logged-in only: tick Require users to be logged-in so guest checkouts never get a tier price. It is off by default.
  • Tiers by spend: order count and total spent conditions target loyal shoppers in the Advanced order and product discount styles, on paid plans.

Customer conditions are on every plan, including the basic free plan (up to 3 basic discounts). The paid plans are Core $29.99, Growth $59.99, Pro $79.99 and Scale $99.99 a month, with Scale for Shopify Plus stores. The plan offered depends on your Shopify plan, and new stores pay $0.99/mo for the first 3 months on any monthly paid plan. Discount Genie reads the tags already on the customer, so tag customers in Shopify admin or with another app.

Best for a tag-only order discount: Howdy Customer Tag Discount

Howdy Customer Tag Discount by macro micro Inc applies percentage order and shipping discounts "based on customer tags", for B2B, wholesale and VIP customers. It is rated 5.0 from 9 reviews and is Built for Shopify, per its Shopify App Store listing, checked November 16, 2026.

It has no free plan. The Basic plan is $19 a month for the customer tag order discount. The Advanced plan is $29 a month and adds the customer tag shipping discount and "Limit the product targets of discount", each with a 14-day free trial, per its Shopify App Store listing, checked November 16, 2026.

Best for the lowest price per month: Oak Customer Tag Discount App

Oak Customer Tag Discount App by Sentalis applies a percent or fixed discount, or a fixed price, on order or shipping "when a logged-in customer matches your tags". Its listing names "Rule priorities, spend caps, start/end dates" and separate rules for B2B, wholesale, VIP and staff. It has no reviews yet, per its Shopify App Store listing, checked November 16, 2026.

The free plan is for development stores only. Basic is $4.99 a month for stores on the Basic Shopify plan, and Pro is $9.99 a month for other stores, each with a 3-day free trial, per its Shopify App Store listing, checked November 16, 2026.

Best for showing tier prices on product pages: TagTier

TagTier by Seota Digital Marketing maps customer tags to price tiers. Its listing says a customer tagged vip-tier-1 will "see that tier price on every product page, cart, and checkout". Its listing says quantity breaks stack on top of tier prices. It is rated 5.0 from 1 review, per its Shopify App Store listing, checked November 16, 2026.

The free plan covers up to 2 tag rules and quantity breaks. Standard is $29 a month for unlimited tag rules, and Plus is $89 a month with an audit log, rollback and CSV import, per its Shopify App Store listing, checked November 16, 2026.

Best for earning VIP tiers with points: Smile: Loyalty Program Rewards

Smile: Loyalty Program Rewards runs loyalty points, referrals and VIP tiers, online and on Shopify POS. Customers earn points and redeem them for rewards such as discounts and free shipping. It is rated 4.9 from 4,681 reviews, per its Shopify App Store listing, checked November 16, 2026.

The free plan covers points, rewards and referrals for up to 200 orders a month. "VIP tiers & Points expiry" are listed on the Growth plan, $199 a month for 2,500 orders a month. Essential is $15 and Standard $79 a month, per its Shopify App Store listing, checked November 16, 2026.

Tier discount apps side by side

Prices and ratings are from each Shopify App Store listing, checked November 16, 2026, per month in US dollars.

AppRatingFree planHow a tier gets its priceLowest plan for tiers
Discount Genie5.0 from 52 reviewsBasic free plan, 3 discountsTag conditions on product, order, tiered, volume, shipping and BOGO discountsBasic free plan
Howdy Customer Tag Discount5.0 from 9 reviewsNonePercentage order or shipping discount per tag$19, Basic
Oak Customer Tag Discount AppNo reviews yetDevelopment stores onlyPercent, fixed or fixed price on order or shipping, per tag$4.99, Basic
TagTier5.0 from 1 reviewUp to 2 tag rulesTier price per tag on product pages, cart and checkoutFree
Smile: Loyalty Program Rewards4.9 from 4,681 reviewsUp to 200 orders a monthPoints program with VIP tiers$199, Growth

FAQ

How do I give Gold, Silver and Bronze customers different discounts on Shopify?

Make one discount per tier. In Shopify, create a segment per tag, such as customer_tags CONTAINS 'Gold', and pick it under Eligibility. In Discount Genie, add a Tags customer condition to each discount; 3 tiers fit on the basic free plan.

How do I stop a customer from getting two tier discounts?

In Discount Genie, exclude the higher tag from the lower tier: Silver gets includes any Silver and excludes any Gold, matched all. In Shopify, remove the old tag when a customer moves up, because a customer with two tags sits in both segments.

Is there a free app for customer tag tier discounts?

Discount Genie's basic free plan covers up to 3 basic discounts with tag conditions, one per tier. TagTier lists up to 2 tag rules on its free plan. Oak's free plan is for development stores only, and Howdy has no free plan.

Does a tier discount work for guest shoppers?

It depends on the tool. Shopify applies a segment discount once checkout recognizes the customer's email address or phone number. Discount Genie reads tags from the logged-in customer, so tick Require users to be logged-in to keep guests off tier prices. See the customer tag guide.