Shopstack Work with us

Guides Plan

Which Shopify app gives a discount on a customer's first order?

Who this guide is for

This guide is for Shopify merchants who want a welcome offer for new customers only, for example 10% off the first order, that a repeat buyer can't use again.

A first order discount has two parts. A popup offers the deal and collects the email address. A rule at checkout checks that the shopper has never ordered before. Some apps do the first part, some do the second.

We compared 8 apps. Every competitor fact comes from the app's Shopify App Store listing, checked on November 21, 2026. We did not install the other apps. Prices are per month, in US dollars, and can change.

Shopstack makes Discount Genie, one of the apps on this list. It is listed first, and every app is described from its own listing.

What Shopify does on its own

Every Shopify discount has an Eligibility section with a Customer segments option. Each item below links the Shopify page it comes from (checked November 21, 2026).

Shopify can

  • Target customers who haven't purchased before with a customer segment of number_of_orders = 0. Source: help.shopify.com
  • Use that segment on discount codes and automatic discounts, up to 5 segments on an automatic discount and up to 100 on a discount code. Source: help.shopify.com

Shopify can’t

  • Require the shopper to be logged in. Shopify identifies the customer by the email address or phone number entered at checkout. Source: help.shopify.com

To give a first order discount without an app:

  1. From your Shopify admin, create a customer segment with number_of_orders = 0.
  2. Go to Discounts and click Create discount.
  3. Set the discount, for example 10% off the order.
  4. In the Eligibility section, select Customer segments, select the segment and click Add.
  5. Click Save.

You need an app once you want a popup that hands out the offer, or once only logged-in customers should get it.

Which app fits your store

Popup tools collect emails and show the offer. A checkout rule decides who gets the discount. Many stores use one of each.

  • A checkout rule for logged-in customers with 0 orders, on codes or automatic discounts: Discount Genie, on paid plans.
  • A single automatic first order discount: Vayu First Order Discount, free plan or $2.99 a month.
  • A one-time discount on the first purchase of chosen products: FirstTry, free for up to 25 orders with a promo.
  • Customer tag and VIP discounts, without a first order rule: Regios Automatic Discounts, from $34.99 a month.
  • A free signup popup: Shopify Forms or Email PopUp & Pop Up Discount.
  • A popup with a welcome email: Klaviyo, free up to 250 active profiles.
  • Email and phone number popups: Pop Convert, free up to 1,000 visitors a month.

Best for a checkout rule on first orders: Discount Genie

Discount Genie by Shopstack has 5.0 from 50+ reviews on the Shopify App Store. Install it from Discount Genie on the Shopify App Store. It is a Shopify discount app built on Shopify Functions, with 11 discount types, including types Shopify doesn't offer, such as volume and tiered discounts.

  • Order count condition: the Advanced order and product discount styles can check how many orders the customer has placed, so an order count of 0 means first order only.
  • Logged-in customers only: Require users to be logged-in is ticked by default once you add a customer condition, and the discount is only verified after the shopper logs into their account. Keep it ticked for a first order discount, or guests count as 0 orders.
  • Codes or automatic: the condition works on discount codes and automatic discounts (create your first discount).
  • Pair with a popup or form app: Discount Genie applies the first order discount. To collect emails and hand out a code, pair it with a popup or form app, and Discount Genie checks eligibility at checkout.

The order count condition is in the Advanced styles, which are on paid plans. The paid plans are Core $29.99, Growth $59.99, Pro $79.99 and Scale $99.99 a month, with Scale for Shopify Plus stores. The plan offered depends on your Shopify plan, and new stores pay $0.99/mo for the first 3 months on any monthly paid plan.

If a plain discount for shoppers with 0 orders is enough, Shopify's own number_of_orders = 0 segment does it for free. With Require users to be logged-in ticked, a guest never gets the Discount Genie discount.

Best for a single automatic first order discount: Vayu First Order Discount

Vayu First Order Discount by Vayu Sharma gives an "Automatic discount for logged-in customers with no previous orders". Its listing explains that "Shopify tells the app a buyer's order count only when they are logged in". Guests don't get the discount unless you turn on a setting that also gives it to guests, and that setting lets returning guests who don't log in use it too. An optional store banner asks visitors to log in. It has 0 reviews, per its Shopify App Store listing, checked November 21, 2026.

It has a Free plan and a Pro plan at $2.99 a month with a 7-day free trial, per its Shopify App Store listing, checked November 21, 2026.

Best for a first purchase deal on chosen products: FirstTry

FirstTry: Product Trial Promos by SMALLROCKS STUDIO LTD gives an "automatic one-time discount on their first purchase of the products you choose". "Each customer gets the deal once per product." It uses no codes, is built on Shopify Functions and shows badges on the storefront. It has 0 reviews, per its Shopify App Store listing, checked November 21, 2026.

The Lite plan is $0 and "Free for up to 25 orders with promo". Pro is $15.99 a month and adds "Target by customer tag" and scheduling, with a 30-day free trial, per its Shopify App Store listing, checked November 21, 2026.

Best for customer tag and VIP discounts: Regios Automatic Discounts

Regios Automatic Discounts by Regios Technologies, Inc. lists customer tag and VIP discounts, volume discounts, Buy X Get Y, gifts and bulk codes. Its listing names no first order or order count condition. It is rated 4.9 from 238 reviews, per its Shopify App Store listing, checked November 21, 2026.

Starter is $34.99 a month for 500 orders a month. Business is $59.99, Enterprise $119.99 and Scale $249.99, each with a 7-day free trial, per its Shopify App Store listing, checked November 21, 2026.

Best free signup popup from Shopify: Shopify Forms

Shopify Forms by Shopify can "Create inline and pop-up forms to collect" subscriber signups and "incentivize with discounts". It works with Shopify Email. It is rated 4.5 from 780 reviews and is free, per its Shopify App Store listing, checked November 21, 2026.

Best for a popup with a welcome email: Klaviyo

Klaviyo: Email Marketing & SMS gives new stores a guided setup with a sign-up form, a welcome email and an abandoned-checkout flow, and it includes pop-ups. Its listing does not say it creates first order discount codes. It is rated 4.7 from 3,464 reviews, per its Shopify App Store listing, checked November 21, 2026.

The Free plan covers up to 250 active profiles and 500 emails a month. SMS is $15 a month and Email is $20 a month. "External charges may be billed by Klaviyo separately", per its Shopify App Store listing, checked November 21, 2026.

Best for email and phone number popups: Pop Convert

Pop Convert helps you "capture emails & phone numbers" with popups. It is rated 4.9 from 8,679 reviews, per its Shopify App Store listing, checked November 21, 2026.

The Free plan covers 1,000 visitors and 50 subscribers a month. The paid plans are named after Shopify plans: Shopify Basic at $15 a month, Shopify Grow at $29 and Shopify Advanced at $79, with $129 a month for Shopify Plus stores and a 90-day free trial, per its Shopify App Store listing, checked November 21, 2026.

Best free discount popup: Email PopUp & Pop Up Discount

Email PopUp & Pop Up Discount by Hoppy Apps has a discount popup to offer discounts and collect emails. It syncs signups to Klaviyo, Mailchimp, Omnisend and Brevo. It is rated 4.9 from 424 reviews and is free, per its Shopify App Store listing, checked November 21, 2026.

First order discount apps side by side

Prices and ratings are from each Shopify App Store listing, checked November 21, 2026, per month in US dollars.

AppRatingWhat it doesFree planLowest paid plan
Discount Genie5.0 from 50+ reviewsCheckout rule: order count for logged-in customersBasic free plan, no order count condition$29.99, Core
Vayu First Order Discount0 reviewsAutomatic discount for logged-in customers with no ordersFree$2.99, Pro
FirstTry: Product Trial Promos0 reviewsOne-time discount on the first purchase of chosen productsUp to 25 orders with promo$15.99, Pro
Regios Automatic Discounts4.9 from 238 reviewsTag, VIP, volume and Buy X Get Y discounts, no first order rule listedNone, 7-day trial$34.99, Starter
Shopify Forms4.5 from 780 reviewsSignup popups and formsFreeNone
Klaviyo: Email Marketing & SMS4.7 from 3,464 reviewsSignup form, pop-ups and welcome emailUp to 250 active profiles$15, SMS
Pop Convert4.9 from 8,679 reviewsEmail and phone number popups1,000 visitors a month$15, Shopify Basic
Email PopUp & Pop Up Discount4.9 from 424 reviewsDiscount popup that collects emailsFreeNone

FAQ

Can Shopify give a first order discount without an app?

Yes. Make a customer segment with number_of_orders = 0 and add it under the discount's Eligibility (Shopify help). Shopify identifies the customer by the email address or phone number entered at checkout.

How do I show a "10% off your first order" popup?

Use a popup app such as Shopify Forms, Klaviyo, Pop Convert or Email PopUp & Pop Up Discount to collect the email and show the code. Then limit the code to new customers with a number_of_orders = 0 segment or a Discount Genie order count condition.

Can guests get a first order discount?

With Shopify's own segment, yes, once checkout recognizes their email address or phone number. Discount Genie's order count check needs the customer to be logged in while Require users to be logged-in is ticked, which is the default. Keep it ticked for a first order discount, or guests count as 0 orders. Vayu First Order Discount also needs the customer to be logged in. Vayu has a setting to include guests, and its listing says returning guests who don't log in can then use it too.

Does Discount Genie have a first order discount?

Yes, on paid plans. Add an order count condition of 0 to an Advanced order or product discount and keep Require users to be logged-in ticked, which is the default. To collect emails and hand out the code, pair it with a popup or form app.